几何尺寸与公差论坛------致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T (GDT:ASME)|New GPS(ISO)研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量  


返回   几何尺寸与公差论坛------致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T (GDT:ASME)|New GPS(ISO)研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量 » 三维空间:产品设计或CAX软件使用 » CAD设计 » 产品功能分析
用户名
密码
注册 帮助 会员 日历 银行 搜索 今日新帖 标记论坛为已读


 
 
主题工具 搜索本主题 显示模式
旧 2009-09-16, 09:17 PM   #1
huangyhg
超级版主
 
huangyhg的头像
 
注册日期: 04-03
帖子: 18592
精华: 36
现金: 249466 标准币
资产: 1080358888 标准币
huangyhg 向着好的方向发展
默认 why we need to repair a bent column

why we need to repair a bent column
suppose i have a steel column struck by something and now has 1/2" bend at the end of one flange. what difference does it make to leave it like that?
find a job or post a job opening
depends on the load on the column (axial, moment, shear)as well as the location.
i would first suggest that you analyze the column with the portion of bent flange missing. include the eccentricity that is developed from the cg of unbent column to the cg of the column you are analyzing including the additional moment developed by the axial load times the eccentricity.
if it checks out ok, then no reinforcing is necessary unless you just want to provide additional protection against damage.
good luck!
if the damage is at free end, it won't make any difference to leave it as it is (may be corrosion problems at worst). in other cases, it increases stresses locally and may affect on stability.
i can think of a number of issues:
- has the center line of the column been moved by the impact? maybe it is not only the flange bent but the whole column distorted. in that case there is now an excentric load, p-delta efects could be significant.
- how badly affected is the flange. how thick it is? half an inch is not the same on a heavy section (in which rolling ofr fabrication tolerances are above that anyway) than on a small thin section. if the sectional properties have been compromised (reduced inertia) then the capacity of the column to buckling has been reduced.
- is the bent local or more gradual?
- is the column subject to any bending moments? if so, then, with reduced i, reduced capacity.
half an inch does not seem significant, but it depends of your section size, column length, loading, ... i can not imagine anybody saying: '1/2"? that's all? not an issue' without consideration to the specific conditions.
if you're in a high-seismic area or you need a lot of ductility in the connection, the buckle can act like a notch and make low-cycle fatigue more of a problem, or a source of fracture.
besides, if you're hired to look at a damaged column and do nothing, if anything ever happens some lawyer might say it happened because you didn't tell them to repair the column. even if it works i would do something to it to cya.
kelowna brings up the aditional issue of general displacement which can add to the eccentricity. another situation that may reduce the capacity is if it is twisted.
but aren't you just as skrew'd if something negative happens in the future and you did repair it in some way ...
in fact, i'd've thought it made matters worse ... "you calculated that my client didn't need to repair the beam, you repaired it, charged him for unnecessary work, and it still fell down ..."
once the lawyers start, the only upside is not going down as far as you might have.
dgkhan,
i would recommend a repair, and design a repair that unequivocally restores the original strength, and show that by calculation.
that way, if there's an issue in the future, you are covered, and it is the original design that was at fault.
i bet that if you can show by calculation, that a 1/2 inch of local bending / twist / warp, whatever you want to call it still checks out as ok, you've probably omitted a crucial calculation, unless the loading conditions have reduced from the original design.
tg
__________________
借用达朗贝尔的名言:前进吧,你会得到信心!
[url="http://www.dimcax.com"]几何尺寸与公差标准[/url]
huangyhg离线中   回复时引用此帖
GDT自动化论坛(仅游客可见)
 


主题工具 搜索本主题
搜索本主题:

高级搜索
显示模式

发帖规则
不可以发表新主题
不可以回复主题
不可以上传附件
不可以编辑您的帖子

vB 代码开启
[IMG]代码开启
HTML代码关闭

相似的主题
主题 主题发起者 论坛 回复 最后发表
urgent - concrete beam to column connection huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-16 05:37 PM
out of plumb column huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-15 10:59 AM
cantilever steel beam at column huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 10:40 PM
bent column flange huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 03:34 PM
another aci slender column question huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 12:13 PM


所有的时间均为北京时间。 现在的时间是 04:33 PM.


于2004年创办,几何尺寸与公差论坛"致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T | GPS研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量"。免责声明:论坛严禁发布色情反动言论及有关违反国家法律法规内容!情节严重者提供其IP,并配合相关部门进行严厉查处,若內容有涉及侵权,请立即联系我们QQ:44671734。注:此论坛须管理员验证方可发帖。
沪ICP备06057009号-2
更多