几何尺寸与公差论坛------致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T (GDT:ASME)|New GPS(ISO)研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量  


返回   几何尺寸与公差论坛------致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T (GDT:ASME)|New GPS(ISO)研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量 » 三维空间:产品设计或CAX软件使用 » CAD设计 » 产品功能分析
用户名
密码
注册 帮助 会员 日历 银行 搜索 今日新帖 标记论坛为已读


回复
 
主题工具 搜索本主题 显示模式
旧 2009-09-08, 12:39 PM   #1
huangyhg
超级版主
 
huangyhg的头像
 
注册日期: 04-03
帖子: 18592
精华: 36
现金: 249466 标准币
资产: 1080358888 标准币
huangyhg 向着好的方向发展
默认 concrete slab and truck load during construction

concrete slab and truck load during construction
this is something that i would be very concerned with.
yes it can be done, but keep in mind, once you give a contractor an inch they'll take a mile (no offense to anyone - i know that they just want to get the job done too).
the slab was initially designed to span say 6 meters. now when you introduce props, each span may be cut into four, or six (whatever). the top and bottom steel in the rc slab will not be placed in the correct location to take the stresses in the concrete.
i would definately get a shoring engineer involved, and have them hired by the contractor. this takes (more of) the responsibility off the building engineer.
there are also a huge variance of truck sizes (this gets back to the give an inch comment). i was once involved in a project where we okayed them to drive small (6m) concrete trucks on the slab. when i arrived for a site review there was a 10m truck off loading. when we gave them the okay to drive on the slab they ignored the limitations simply because "the concrete came in a bigger truck".
this issue arises often, and supports my theory that builders should also be involved in the design stage such that the (easy) change to support construction loading could be made during the design stage.
just my two cents.
cottageguy
good note cottageguy.
that is my experience as well.
i would caution you as a design engineer or client representative from becoming involved in any engineering on the part of the contractor. this contractor needs to hire an engineer to evaluate his means and method and ultimately sign and seal plans, calcs, specifications. it is up to you to approve or disapprove the means and method based on the integrity of the structure and any short/long term influence. also, once approved it is up to the owner, or firm employed to ensure compliance by the contractor to the specifications of the project, to see that the contractor doesn't take any risks beyond what his engineer prescribed.
why allow driving the truck on the slab when concrete conveyors and pumps are available? you have answered your own question, the slab isn't designed for it. shoring the slab to allow the truck traffic will cost more than the conveyor or pump rental! of course, there is also the option of concrete buggies. they could be filled at the truck and driven onto the slab with much less of a load effect. but, i still believe the conveyor or pump would be less expensive.
jheidt,
as a designer, i completely agree. pumps, conveyors and buggies will all work for offloading. but thinking as a contractor, i just want to get the concrete out of the truck as quickly and easily as possible. the closer they can get to the pour or crane the quicker (and cheaper) the work will be done.
if shoring is required, i have found that the contractor easily accepts the fact that they just can't drive on the slab, without spending more money and time. i don't blame them for asking.
i had a design-build project in a downtown core, where the contractor asked to do this during the design stage. we simply changed the load and beefed up the slab at his request. might be something to keep in mind at those perliminary design meetings.
cottageguy.
if there is a problem after the fact, you may not be covered by your professional liability insurance either in a situation like that, since it sounds like an out of scope/contract situation. i have worked on several bridge analyses where contractors want to drive a crane across an existing bridge. in such a case we are the contractor's "specialty" engineer, hired and paid by the contractor.
__________________
借用达朗贝尔的名言:前进吧,你会得到信心!
[url="http://www.dimcax.com"]几何尺寸与公差标准[/url]
huangyhg离线中   回复时引用此帖
GDT自动化论坛(仅游客可见)
回复


主题工具 搜索本主题
搜索本主题:

高级搜索
显示模式

发帖规则
不可以发表新主题
不可以回复主题
不可以上传附件
不可以编辑您的帖子

vB 代码开启
[IMG]代码开启
HTML代码关闭

相似的主题
主题 主题发起者 论坛 回复 最后发表
bonding between existing concrete slab and new overlay huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 04:22 PM
bonded floor slab 9meaning concrete slab with a concrete ove huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 04:20 PM
affects of air entrainmen huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 10:21 AM
aasho load help huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 09:18 AM
200 kip vehicle load huangyhg 产品功能分析 0 2009-09-07 08:24 AM


所有的时间均为北京时间。 现在的时间是 04:50 PM.


于2004年创办,几何尺寸与公差论坛"致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T | GPS研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量"。免责声明:论坛严禁发布色情反动言论及有关违反国家法律法规内容!情节严重者提供其IP,并配合相关部门进行严厉查处,若內容有涉及侵权,请立即联系我们QQ:44671734。注:此论坛须管理员验证方可发帖。
沪ICP备06057009号-2
更多